American Caramel E91 Baseball Card Set

The American Caramel E91 Baseball Card Set was produced from 1908-1910. It is believed to be the company’s first set ever produced. The complete contains a total of 99 cards consisting of 3 sub sets of 33 cards each. Each card has a size of approximately 1-1/2 x 2-3/4.

The American Caramel Baseball Card sets don’t gain the popularity of others during this era as random photos are used for different players. In some instances; the same photo is used for 3 different people!

Gary Leavitt has been collecting American Caramel Baseball Card sets for years and is interested in adding any you want to sell to his collection. Contact us for more information.

The Three Subsets

• Set A from 1908 has backs that include the Athletics/New York/Chicago (World Series Champions) team checklist
• Set B from 1909 has backs that include the Chicago/Athletics/New York team checklist
• Set C from 1910 has backs that include the Pittsburgh/Washington/Boston team checklist

Set A Checklist:

1. Ralph Seybold
2. Rube Oldring
3. Eddie Plank
4. Dan Murphy
5. Harry Davis
6. Rube Waddell
7. Fred Hartsel
8. Jimmy Collins
9. Simon Nichols
10. Ossee Schreckengost
11. Chief Bender
12. Luther Taylor
13. Fred Tenney
14. Albert Bridwell
15. John McGraw
16. Christy Mathewson
17. Iron Man McGinnity
18. J.B. Seymour
19. Daniel Shay
20. Art Devlin
21. Michael Donlin
22. Roger Bresnahan
23. Harry Steinfeldt
24. Johnny Evers
25. Mordecai Brown
26. Frank Chance
27. James Sheckard
28. Joe Tinker
29. Orval Overall
30. Johnny Kling
31. Ed Reulbach
32. James Slagle
33. Frank Schulte

Set B Checklist:

1. James Archer
2. Mordecai Brown
3. Ed Reulbach
4. Orval Overall
5. Frank Chance
6. Johnny Evers
7. Joe Tinker
8. Harry Steinfeldt
9. James Sheckard
10. Frank Schulte
11. Art Hoffman
12. Dan Murphy
13. Bob Ganley
14. Eddie Plank
15. Eddie Collins
16. Harry Davis
17. Harry Krause
18. Fred Hartsell
19. Home Run Baker
20. John Barry
21. Ira Thomas
22. Chief Bender
23. J.T. Meyers
24. Christy Mathewson
25. John McGraw
26. Rube Marquard
27. Fred Tenney
28. Larry Doyle
29. Albert Bridwell
30. Art Devlin
31. Jno Murray
32. Michael Donlin
33. J.B. Seymour

Set C Checklist:

1. George Gibson
2. Vic Willis
3. Sam Leever
4. Charles Phillipi
5. Allen Storke
6. J.B. Miller
7. Jap Barbeau
8. Fred Clarke
9. Tommy Leach
10. Owen Wilson
11. Honus Wagner
12. Charles Street
13. Tom Hughes
14. Bob Groom
15. Walter Johnson
16. Jon Donohue
17. James Delehanty
18. Wid Conroy
19. George McBride
20. George Browne
21. Clyde Milan
22. Bob Unglaub
23. P. Donohue
24. Ed Karger
25. Bob Chech
26. Smoky Joe Wood
27. Jake Stahl
28. Ambrose McConnell
29. Harry Lord
30. Harry Hooper
31. Tris Speaker
32. Harry Niles
33. C. Wagner